JEMS Connect - EMS Emergency Medical Services

Social and Professional Network

okay - i am doing a paper on the ethics behind the supervised injection site (currently in vancouver) and was wondering about other people opinion on the topic. For those that don't understand what it really is - a supervised injection site is where in partnership with the city a site has been set up for drug users to get clean needles but also there is supervision there in the case of overdose etc. Is it ethically correct to be supervising a site like this (where in a essence you could be considered as assisting a drug user)
- open to your opinions
Sandra - third year student nurse

Share

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Ben Waller said:
"Only" risking federal prison time for drug dealing for medical marijuana? "Only"????
That's like saying that childbirth without an epidural "only" hurts the mother a little bit.

I'd argue that the chances of facing federal charges for medicinal marijuana dealing is significantly less than the average street dealer. Especially considering that, due to the nature of the business, medical marijuana dealers have to operate out in the open and are still around. It's a risk of the business and not a risk to be underestimated.

Reply to This

Ben Waller said:
Anyway, it was just announced (CNN, 11 PM news) that the Administration has directed federal prosecutors to stop prosecuting medical marijuana cases. Anyone feeling sick?
Yes, but only because if I had to design the worst possible delivery device for a medication, I would insist that pts inhale lungfuls of toxic smoke along with the med.... :D Marijuana certainly has certain legitimate medicinal properties but brownies or hash oil would be a much better delivery device (although the food scolds would certainly debate me on the brownies).

Reply to This

dr-exmedic said:
Yes, but only because if I had to design the worst possible delivery device for a medication, I would insist that pts inhale lungfuls of toxic smoke along with the med.... :D Marijuana certainly has certain legitimate medicinal properties but brownies or hash oil would be a much better delivery device (although the food scolds would certainly debate me on the brownies).

CNBC produced a special called "Marijuana Inc: Inside America's Pot Industry." One of the things that they covered was medical marijuana including one of the popular dispensaries in Oakland. They had just about every delivery method that you could think of, including various food items.

Here's a clip from the CNBC website. http://www.cnbc.com/id/15840232?play=1&video=995212168

Reply to This

Hey, ExMedic. I think I have glaucoma. Can you help me? :P

dr-exmedic said:
Ben Waller said:
Anyway, it was just announced (CNN, 11 PM news) that the Administration has directed federal prosecutors to stop prosecuting medical marijuana cases. Anyone feeling sick?
Yes, but only because if I had to design the worst possible delivery device for a medication, I would insist that pts inhale lungfuls of toxic smoke along with the med.... :D Marijuana certainly has certain legitimate medicinal properties but brownies or hash oil would be a much better delivery device (although the food scolds would certainly debate me on the brownies).

Reply to This

Chance Gearheart said:
Hey, ExMedic. I think I have glaucoma. Can you help me? :P
There are many things I will do but move to CA is not one of them. Now when PA gets its own medical marijuana law, then we'll talk. ;)

I think my favorite interview of a medical MJ patient was a woman who got it prescribed for PMS, and the interviewer asked "So you smoke it 4 or 5 days out of the month, then?" and the pt said, "No, every day."
CNBC produced a special called "Marijuana Inc: Inside America's Pot Industry." One of the things that they covered was medical marijuana including one of the popular dispensaries in Oakland. They had just about every delivery method that you could think of, including various food items.
Yeah, you can satisfy your munchies as you get them. :)

Reply to This

I think that on the surface the ethical issue stems from the perception that providing clean needles is in essence condoning the drug habit and all the crime that surrounds the drug user. Another way to look at it is from the benefits vs. risk perspective. I think we can all list the risks, but here are the benefits as I perceive them:
1. drug addicts come into a centre where, in addition to giving them clean needles, there is an opportunity start a dialogue and hopefully connect with them and help them kick the addiction and rehabilitate.
2. clean needles reduces the incidence of local and systemic infection thus lowering the health care costs that we ALL pay for (whether you're Canadian or American or from anywhere else)
3. public health gets a much clearer picture of the problem and the people who are affected.

Ethics asside, I think it's primarily a case of the benefits outweigh the risks.

cheers
Rob (my blog: Paramedic Tutor)

Reply to This

Reply to This

RSS

Attend Our Next Webcast

Add Contacts Now

Invite your EMS co-workers & friends to join your network. They'll automatically be added to your Friends List. Click Now

Latest Activity

Karen joined Steve Pack's group
A place for Paramedics who are RN's or anyone interested in the merging of the two worlds.
3 hours ago
As a newly-licenced paramedic, I also agree that the current system is flawed. My clinicals alternated between extremely good and a few situations where I was the most-senior person on the truck...as a student. The problem isn't limited to the civ...
6 hours ago
2 members updated their profile photos
6 hours ago
doc, You are also forgetting the relative call volumes and the effect they have. Law enforcement is the busiest function (crime fighting) so the cops have the least time to devote to other, non-crime-fighting functions. That makes it intutively o...
6 hours ago

Member Search

Search by Name, Location, Agency, Keyword
  

JEMS Connect is the social and professional network for emergency medical services, EMS, paramedics, EMT, rescue squad, BLS, ALS and more.

© 2009   JEMS / Elsevier Public Safety    Our Sites: JEMS.com - EMS Today Conference & Expo 2009 - FireRescue    Partners Firefighter Nation
Commercial Use Limitations: Use of any content features (blogs, forums, messaging, etc) for direct self-promotion, spamming, etc. will result in account termination. Profiles are for individuals only at this time. Profile icons may not include company logos.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service